Chakli vs Murukku: The Besan Bite Gives Chakli Away
Chakli and murukku are close cousins, not identical twins. Both are press-extruded, spiral-shaped fried snacks, but murukku is the South Indian classic with a lighter, rice-and-urad snap, while chakli is the western Indian version that usually adds besan for a heartier bite. Below we cover origins, ingredients, texture, cooking, and a quick way to tell them apart. We handcraft snacks at DesiMunchiess, so we care about every detail.
TL;DR:
A ridged or spiked surface, tighter coils, and a toasted aroma can point to chakli, but regional recipes often break these clues.
For a crisp batch, use oil at medium heat, fry in small batches until bubbling slows, and cool the coils fully before airtight storage.
Both are deep fried treats, and people with medical conditions or dietary restrictions should ask a doctor or dietitian before eating them regularly.
Choose coils with an even golden color, a clean snap, and a fresh toasted aroma; dark edges, greasy texture, or stale smells signal poor quality.
Table of Contents
Where did chakli and murukku come from?
Both snacks share a long family tree, and the names point to different regions.
Murukku is tied to South India, including Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, and Kerala. The name comes from the Tamil word for “twisting,” a nod to its spiral shape.
Chakli is associated with western and central India. You may also see it spelled chakali or chakri.
Early roots go back a long way. An early precursor called “saskuli” appears in ancient Ayurvedic texts, and the medieval cookbook Soopa Shastra (1509 AD) has a recipe closely resembling modern chakli made from rice, Bengal gram, and urad dal flours.
Shared ancestry explains why the two look so alike. Families carried recipes across states, and each kitchen tweaked them.
So when someone asks which came first, the honest answer is that they grew up together, shaped by the same press and the same love of a good crunch.
What goes into the dough?
Ingredients tell you most of the story. Think of the dough as the snack’s personality.
Murukku typically starts with rice flour and urad dal (black gram) flour. That combination gives a light, rice-forward snap.
Chakli usually uses rice flour plus Bengal gram flour (besan), often with urad dal as well. The besan adds a nuttier, denser bite.
Shared seasonings include sesame seeds, cumin, hing (asafoetida), salt, and chili. Family recipes vary a lot, so no two batches taste exactly alike.
Chakli’s commonly listed main ingredients are rice flour, Bengal gram flour, and black gram flour. That third flour, besan, is the quiet difference that separates chakli from the plainer murukku base.
Spice matters just as much as flour, and you can learn about how to integrate maca powder into recipes on this granola cacao-maca aux graines de chia et de lin site. Indian cooks have long used spices in whole, toasted, and powdered forms to build layered flavor, a habit the Institute of Culinary Education describes in its look at how Indian cooking uses spice. In snacks, that balance keeps the earthy lentils and neutral rice from tasting flat. If you want to explore less common flours and spices, our home cook’s guide to exotic desi snack ingredients goes deeper.
How do texture and shape differ?
Ingredient ratios and press dies shape the final crunch.
Besan makes a denser, more substantial bite. Rice and urad dal tend to give a brittle, clean snap.
Surface is a good clue. Chakli often has a spiked or ridged look from a star-shaped die, while murukku is frequently smoother.
Strand thickness and coil tightness change how the snack breaks. Thin, loose coils shatter easily. Thick, tight coils feel sturdier.
Frying time decides how crisp the finish is. A few seconds too long turns golden into bitter.
A good snack should be brittle enough to snap easily without crumbling, and crisp without being jaw-breakingly hard. That texture balance is a hallmark of well-made chakli, and the same goal applies to murukku.
Pro Tip: Listen for the snap. Break one coil near your ear. A sharp, clean crack means it is fried through, while a dull bend means it needs more time or was fried too cool.
How are they made?
The method looks similar for both, which is part of why the names blur. The details are what change the result.
Dough consistency matters first. A softer dough pushes through the press easily and gives fine, delicate strands. A stiffer dough holds ridges better, which suits a spiked chakli. Die choice then sets the surface: a star die leaves ridges, and a plain round die leaves a smooth strand.
Here is the basic path from flour to snack:
Mix the flours with salt, seeds, hing, and chili.
Add warm water or a little butter and knead into a soft, pliable dough.
Fill the press with the dough and pick the die you want.
Press spirals onto a greased sheet or directly into the oil.
Fry in medium-hot oil until the bubbling slows and the coils turn golden.
Drain, cool fully, and store airtight.
Small batches keep the oil clean and the temperature steady, which is how we like to work. If you enjoy the craft side, our post on traditional Indian snack making techniques walks through shaping, pressing, and frying.
Pro Tip: Fry in small batches with fresh oil. Crowding the pan drops the temperature, and that makes greasy, soft snacks instead of crisp ones.
Why do the names overlap across regions?
The lines blur because food travels with people. Here are the names you will meet:
Murukku: South India.
Chakli, chakali, chakri: names used for related snacks.
Chakkuli and jantikalu: regional names for related snacks.
Festival sharing and migration are the big reasons. During Diwali, families swap snack boxes across states, and identical or near-identical snacks can carry different names depending on who is serving them.
Picture one family recipe. A grandmother in Tamil Nadu makes murukku with rice and urad. Her granddaughter moves to Pune, adds a spoonful of besan because the local flour is easy to find, and her neighbors call it chakli. Same hands, same press, new name. Our guide to North vs South Indian snacks shows how often that happens.
How can you tell them apart quickly?
When no label is around, use your eyes first, then your tongue.
Visual cues
Spiky or ridged surface points to chakli; a smoother strand points to murukku.
Thicker, tighter coils usually mean chakli; finer, lighter coils lean murukku.
A deeper golden-brown often signals besan in the mix.
Taste cues
A nutty, earthy note means besan, so think chakli.
A clean rice-and-urad snap with a lighter finish suggests murukku.
No label? Try this
Smell it. Besan gives a toasty, roasted aroma.
Snap one coil. A dense, firm break leans chakli; a light, glassy break leans murukku.
Treat these as strong hints, not rules. Regional recipes break every pattern at some point, and that is part of the fun.
How do they compare nutritionally?
Both are deep-fried snacks, so they are treats, not everyday staples. The healthier choice is mostly about the dough and the oil.
Besan changes chakli’s flour mix compared with a plain rice-and-urad base. Urad dal adds some protein to both. Both are fried snacks, so consider the ingredients and serving size when choosing between them.
A few habits make a difference:
Pick snacks fried in fresh, good-quality oil.
Check how salty and spicy the seasoning is if you watch sodium.
Enjoy a small handful with tea rather than eating from the bag.
Store them airtight so they stay crisp and you need less to feel satisfied.
Neither snack is a diet food, and we would not pretend otherwise. If you have a medical condition or dietary restriction, check with your doctor or a dietitian before making these a regular habit.
What do they taste like?
Flavor follows the flour. Murukku tastes lighter and more rice-forward, with a gentle toasty note from urad dal and a clean, snappy finish. The seasoning sits in the background, so you often notice sesame and cumin first.
Chakli tastes bolder and rounder. Besan adds a nutty, almost roasted depth, and many recipes lean harder on chili, ajwain, or cumin. The bite feels more substantial, which makes it a good match for strong tea.
Both snacks depend on spice balance. Too little, and the dal tastes flat. Too much, and it hides the grain. Indian cooks learned long ago that layering whole, toasted, and ground spices builds depth, and the best coils taste complete rather than loud. If you like heat, our spicy Indian snacks list has more to try.
A useful comparison comes from another pair, sev and bhujia. Small flour swaps and spice changes can shift texture and taste a lot, and the same logic explains why one spoonful of besan changes a murukku into a chakli.
When do people serve them?
Diwali is the big one. Families make or buy big batches of chakli and murukku weeks ahead, pack them in tins, and share them with neighbors and relatives. That sharing is exactly why the names travel.
Outside Diwali, you will see them at:
Weddings and housewarming gifts, in decorated boxes.
Evening tea time, as a crunchy side with chai or coffee.
Festivals like Ganesh Chaturthi, Pongal, and Janmashtami, depending on the region.
Lunchboxes and train trips, since they keep well when stored airtight.
Snacks like these mean more than crunch. They carry memory: the sound of the press, the smell of hot oil, the family gathered around a plate. That is the feeling we try to bring to every product at DesiMunchiess.
What should you look for in a good one?
Our view: quality shows up in small, honest details. We make our snacks with authentic, traditional recipes and handcrafted, small-batch methods, because freshness and flavor start in the kitchen.
When you shop for chakli or murukku, look for:
Aroma: fresh frying oil and toasted spice, never stale or sharp.
Crispness: a clean snap, not a bendy or greasy bite.
Balance: salt and chili that support the grain instead of covering it.
Even color: golden throughout, with no dark, burnt edges.
Freshness is an important quality to look for, alongside the information on the label. If a snack smells flat, it will taste flat.
— Shivam
FAQ
What’s the difference between murukku and chakli?
Murukku is a South Indian snack usually made from rice flour and urad dal, with a lighter, smoother, brittle snap. Chakli, popular in western India, typically adds Bengal gram flour (besan), which makes it denser and often spikier on the surface.
What is called chakli in English?
There is no single English name, so people usually just say “chakli.” It is often described as a spiral-shaped, deep-fried savory snack made from rice and lentil flours. You may also see it written as chakali or chakri.
What is murukku made of?
Murukku is traditionally made from rice flour and urad dal (black gram) flour, seasoned with salt, sesame seeds, cumin, and hing. The dough is pressed into spirals and deep-fried until crisp.
Is chakli Maharashtrian or Gujarati?
It is both, and more. Chakli is strongly associated with Maharashtra and Gujarat, and families in both states make it, especially for Diwali. Its earliest precursor goes back much further than either state’s modern kitchens.
Sources
Recommended
Comments